Friday, September 25, 2009

Normal Conflict in Intimate Relationships

Sometimes there is a buzz between Mike and me. I'm blessed to report that after nearly 13 years of marriage, the chemistry still sizzles, sometimes hotter than ever. Don't worry; I'll spare you the details.

Such interest in each other has been especially true in recent weeks. This comes after working through a normal phase of "storming" in which we frequently offended each other. I am convinced that every intimate relationship will eventually go through what Tuckman and Jensen describe as, The Storming Phase.[1]

Tuckman and Jensen (1997) suggest the normal progression of groups (and I am applying their terms to couples) begins by getting to know one another. This first phase is called The Forming Stage. Couples then enter into a second period called the Storming Phase, which is a time of increased conflict. These difficulties occur before the couple develops a clear understanding of how their relationship will operate—which will occur in the third phase, called Norming. This transition out of conflict occurs when the couple works through (true success) or manages to ignore (fake success) the issues presented during the Storming Phase. After Norming, the couple enters into the fourth stage called Performing, or the Working Stage. It is here that the couple is able to work together productively and comfortably. Inevitably, every group and couple will find themselves “adjourning,” the fifth and final stage. Even happily married couples will eventually part, even if only because of death.

In my estimation, normal groups and marriages go through several cycles of storming, norming, and performing with successively higher or lower levels of functioning after each round. Whether the relationship grows or dies depends upon using the right tools, reinventing certain aspects of the relationship, and not freaking out in a destructive manner.

We don’t always get it right, and there were many missteps. However, over all Mike and I managed to keep the lines of communication open during this last Storming Phase and refrained from blaming each other. Multiple times, we took a break from the work, and resigned to simply hurt together. Since we believe God is the author of all love, we prayed and reminded ourselves of basic biblical truths. There was no grand moment or epiphany. After a while, we simply found ourselves at a new, greater level of liking, passion, and commitment. It’s a great stage to be in, and after many years, it seems these satisfying stages usually last for longer periods of time.

It’s normal to experience conflict in relationships. It is not normal to experience complete agreement with anyone. Shallow peace is almost always a sign that someone is withholding the truth or that the relationship lacks depth.

While conflict is normal, it should not last for too long or be destructive. A sign that the Storming Phase has successfully passed is that opportunities for connection increase, not decrease. When several cycles occur without true resolution, the couple may find themselves unable to enter many rooms of the relational house. Obtaining outside help from a pastor, counselor, group, or educational resource will likely be necessary if the couple wishes to realize their potential.

There is reason to believe couples who hold onto themselves, refrain from attacking, seek wisdom, and cling to the God who is love, will find their way through normal conflict with great rewards for their perseverance.

In Mike’s famous words: Press On!






[1] Gladding, Samuel T.(2008). Groups: a counseling specialty, (5th ed.). (pp. 107). Ohio: Pearson Merrill Prentice Hall.

Sunday, September 6, 2009

Making Decisions as a Couple 101

I just watched a great message on TV from Andy Stanley called, "Staying in Love." Some of you know how harsh a critic I am of Christian authors/speakers, etc., so I rarely endorse anything. You can get a copy of the message at https://www.intouchbookstore.org/index.html?getProduct=090607D


Among other things, the message does an excellent job of describing the concept of submission within loving and Christ-centered relationships. He uses the term so many counselors and pastors are coming to use: "Mutual Submission."

For the first several years of our marriage,I operated as if biblical submission required me to willingly go along with Mike's final decision. This was mostly a product of my convictions. It was a romantic and old-fashioned idea that I imagined had worked so well for centuries before the women's lib era.

I loved the idea of being submissive to Mike although I never believed I was inferior to him. After all, this policy basically got me off the hook for I did not have to think for myself. It meant that Mike could never be wrong (because he was the head through whom God spoke and Mike could not ever have heard incorrectly!), so if I didn't like something, the problem lied within me. Frankly, I'd rather believe the problem is with me because I can control myself. I cannot control Mike.

Although appealing to me, this system for making decisions as a couple was not grounded in Scripture and ultimately contributed to the near break up of our marriage--now nearly 5 years ago. Whether I could see at the time or not, I became increasingly judgmental towards both of us for neither of us could keep the gig up. In my mind, Mike was never a strong enough leader, and I was never completely satisfied with erasing my opinions and desires. Praise God for a new start!

Among other problems that needed fresh solutions, our marriage counselor introduced this idea of "mutual submission." True, Ephesians 5:22 says, "Wives, submit to your husbands as to the Lord." But the verse before this (vs. 21) tells us to, "Submit to one another out of reverence for Christ." In other words, we are to submit to one another. It does seem for some reason, that the women need an extra reminder.

And perhaps the reminder is good for women today as well. The way I see it, our culture is so women-centered that even our eight year-old son protested, "Every where I look--the TV, the stores, everything I see says that girls are better than boys!" Is that not true? Due to advances in technology and agriculture, most of the outlets for the instincts and skills that are hard-wired into the male brain find their only outlets through video games, engines, and sports. It is easy, as a woman, to feel I am superior; everything around me seems to tell me that what I am best at is more important. However, I thought I was pretty smart until we went camping! Praise God for making us different and equal!

I realize that gender issues and roles are big topics with lots of good people on both sides. I'm not trying to stir up controversy.

However, I like the way Stanley put it, "When couples submit to one another, there is no one in charge ordering people around. No one is trying to get their way. The arguments go something like this, 'I'll serve you," "No, I'll serve you." etc., etc.

After all, how can you be in love without a balance of power? When the relationship mostly meets the needs of one person, it becomes parental. And good luck feeling romantic around someone who reminds you of your mother!


Romance is nice, but decisions must still be made. In many ways, the couple is a team and having an agreed upon system is essential for making sure everyone's needs are being met.

Sometime ago, Mike and I rewrote our pact for decision making, and we've taught it to many others who have found it to be helpful. In making decisions that impact us both (the majority of decisions, but not all), we agree:

1) If we disagree, we will postpone the decision, if possible.

2) If we disagree and a decision must be made quickly, the person with the most expertise in that area will make the decision. (This requires you to brainstorm on who knows the most about what.) Of course, the expert takes the other into consideration and can change his/her original position.

3) If we disagree and time is running out, and if we cannot agree on who the expert is, we defer to Mike.

True, this puts the responsibility on Mike, but he's better suited for it than I am. And that I think, is probably biblical. By the way, I doubt we've had to invoke #3 more than 5 times in 5 years. Because we will have to wait if we don't agree, we can usually find a happy compromise that is mutually beneficially.

We ask couples we counsel to either agree to some form of this in writing or come up with their own system for making decisions.

It works!

Have a great day off! ~Mike and Jennifer Brost