Tuesday, August 11, 2009

No Boundaries=No Love

Christian authors Dr. Henry Cloud and Dr. John Townsend published their groundbreaking work called, "Boundaries" in the early 1990s. Since then, the word "boundaries" has become a household word. What does a boundary look like and how do they help?



Luke and Monica are getting dressed for an engagement party. Luke knows the bride and groom better than Monica does, but he is not as excited about the party as Monica would like him to be. Monica is naturally outgoing and fears she will once again feel embarrassed by her husband's relatively withdrawn and quiet behavior. She feels his behavior is rude and reflects upon her image.



"That's what you are going to wear?" This question was Monica's way of disguising her statement.



"What's wrong with it?" Luke pretends to not be annoyed by his wife's motherly behavior.



"Well, for one thing, it doesn't match. And it is old. And it's wrinkled...." Monica doesn't even notice that Luke's not listening. She stops her ranting only after she realizes that Luke is back in the closet.



Monica hand picks Luke's outfit. Luke complies.



"Oh, by the way," Monica says, encouraged by Luke's willingness to be subjected by her, "I think you should congratulate the couple and then ask them about the wedding plans. But don't be too shocked if the date isn't set in stone or they're going to elope. You know, just try to act natural."



"Natural!" Luke thinks, "If I act 'natural' she'll hang me out to dry!"



"Ok, dear." Luke says. He drives his wife to the party. Monica has no idea what Luke is feeling. Luke does not really realize what is going on either. He only knows he does not feel good.



At the party, Luke shakes hands with the couple. He congratulates them and then leaves Monica to lead the rest of the conversation. They leave the party early and have an openly hostile fight.



Where are the boundary violations in this true to life scenario? Was it any of Monica's business what her husband wore? No. What people wear is their business, to attempt to force someone to dress in a way that pleases you is a violation. Luke violated his own boundaries by allowing his wife to dictate something as personal as his attire.



What about the advice Monica gave in regards to carrying on a conversation? If Luke does act shy and withdrawn, is that really a reflection upon Monica? Does it even really mean that Luke looks poorly? Is the party about the engaged couple or Monica and Luke's image?

Monica violates herself by doing for Luke that which was not her responsibility. Luke finally sets his boundary and stands up for himself by refusing to bow the knee to Monica; however, in doing so he violates his own sense of right and wrong. The truth is, he was a little interested in the couple's wedding plans. He chose to withdraw (nothing wrong with that), but did so not out of conviction but rather out of shear exhaustion from his allowance of many, many violations.



Drs. Townsend and Cloud say that people have God-given rights to their feelings, attitudes, beliefs, behaviors and their natural consequences, choices and preferences, values, ability to say no, talents, thoughts, desires, and love. Although we might try, we cannot control these in others. We resent having someone attempt to control us.

In a few days, I'll post on how to set your boundaries with love and integrity. I'll also give you some thoughts on how to state your wants and desires without violating your loved one's boundaries.

You can't obtain intimacy with someone when they are merely playing the tape they think you want them to play. You don't really know yourself if you are simply doing in order to avoid.

Have a great day!

No comments:

Post a Comment